Mallpocalypse: The End of Retail Hubs and a Look Into Their Future
Introduction
Once hailed as the epitome of modern urban design, the shopping mall has become a symbol of an era gone by. The Southdale Centre in Edina, Minnesota, which opened its doors in 1956, marked the dawn of a retail revolution as the first ever fully enclosed shopping space. Designed by Victor Gruen, this pioneering mall was envisioned as more than just a shopping destination; it was a community hub, blending retail with amenities and services in a climate-controlled environment. For decades, malls flourished across America and Canada, embodying the spirit of suburban expansion and consumer culture.
However, this golden age of malls is now in decline. The forces that once propelled their growth—suburban sprawl, an explosion of retail space, and a relentless push for consumerism—have turned against them. Today, many malls stand as abandoned shells of their former selves, grappling with high vacancy rates and declining foot traffic. The rise of e-commerce, shifting consumer preferences, and the over saturation of mall developments have collectively contributed to their downfall. There are currently 1,150 malls in the U.S., and some sources project that there will be as few as 150 malls left standing in 2032. This statistic is an alarmingly stark indicator of the broader malaise affecting the retail sector.
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​Fig 1. U.S. mall vacancy rate over time.
​
Yet, amid this decline lies a realm of opportunity. The vacant spaces left by shuttered malls offer a blank canvas for redevelopment. Investors and developers are now exploring innovative ways to repurpose these properties, turning them into vibrant, mixed-use communities that blend retail, residential, and recreational spaces. This transformation addresses the changing needs of modern consumers and provides a unique investment opportunity in a space ripe for reinvention.
In this report, we will explore the decline of shopping malls, focusing on the factors contributing to their reduced relevance in today’s retail environment. We will also delve into investment opportunities associated with the redevelopment of these spaces, examining how strategic repositioning can capitalize on emerging trends and market demands.
Death
The decline of shopping malls in the United States is a complex tale of cultural shifts, changing consumer behaviours, and the inevitable march of technology. At their peak, malls were not just retail hubs but community centers, places where people gathered for shopping, socializing, and entertainment. However, by the early 2000s, cracks began to show in this once-thriving retail model, leading to what some analysts now call the "retail apocalypse."
​​
Changing Consumer Landscape
One of the primary reasons for the downfall of malls is the shift in consumer habits, particularly the rise of e-commerce. The convenience of online shopping has fundamentally altered the way people purchase goods. By 2022, it was estimated that one out of every four malls in the U.S. could be out of business, as shoppers increasingly opted to buy everything from clothing to electronics online. This shift has led to significant store closures, with more than 8,600 retail stores shutting their doors in 2024 alone, many of them the once-vital anchor tenants like Sears, Macy's, and JCPenney.
​​
Over-Retailing and Market Saturation
Another significant factor in the decline of malls is over-retailing. The U.S. has more retail space per capita than any other country, with approximately 26 square feet of retail space for every person, compared to just 2.5 square feet per capita in Europe. This overabundance of retail space, coupled with the rise of online shopping, created a perfect storm that led to a sharp decline in mall viability. Class C malls, those generating less than $300 in annual sales per square foot, have been particularly hard hit, with a staggering 10.2% vacancy rate in 2023, compared to a 3.6% vacancy rate in more successful Class A malls, malls with more than $500 in annual sales per square foot.
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​​
​
​​
​
​
​
​
​
Fig 2. Retail real estate vacancy rates.
​
Cultural Shifts and the Decline of Social Spaces
Malls were designed for a different era, one where people had more leisure time and fewer digital distractions. In today’s fast-paced, digital-first world, the leisurely shopping and socializing that once defined the mall experience have become less relevant. Younger generations, in particular, view malls as relics of the past, preferring the immediacy and efficiency of online interactions. This cultural shift has further eroded the foot traffic that malls once relied on to thrive.​​
​
Revival
The revival of dead malls requires a strategic and innovative approach that leverages their existing infrastructure to meet the evolving needs of communities. One promising avenue is the transformation of these spaces into human services centers, providing essential services such as fitness, wellness, healthcare, job training, and education. These centers can also incorporate mixed-income housing, daycare, elder care, and community-focused retail, creating vibrant hubs of activity that serve a broad range of public needs. Communities can repurpose malls into valuable assets that enhance local economies and social cohesion by forging public-private partnerships and utilizing catalytic capital.
​
Private equity firms are increasingly targeting underperforming malls, seeing potential in transforming these spaces into vibrant mixed-use environments. By acquiring malls with strategic locations or redevelopment potential, private equity investors can repurpose them into residential, office, and entertainment hubs, breathing new life into once-dying retail centers. This revitalization often involves comprehensive renovations, rebranding efforts, and the introduction of innovative uses tailored to current market demands. This approach mirrors the strategies employed in the hotel industry, where private equity has successfully reinvigorated hotels by acquiring properties, renovating them, and rebranding to enhance guest experiences and drive profitability. Both sectors benefit from similar investment philosophies: a deep evaluation of assets, targeted redevelopment, and a focus on aligning properties with evolving consumer trends. This parallel approach underscores how private equity’s revitalization strategies can effectively transform both malls and hotels into profitable, high-demand assets.
​
One notable trend is the successful transformation of malls into vibrant mixed-use neighbourhoods. A prime example is the Pentagon Centre in Arlington, Virginia, where the Witmer—a luxury apartment building with upscale amenities—has integrated seamlessly into the mall environment, demonstrating high leasing success shortly after its opening. This success story is reflected nationwide, with developers converting outdated malls into communities that blend residential, retail, and recreational spaces. These projects not only address housing shortages but also revitalize the surrounding retail areas by placing potential consumers in close proximity. By replacing expansive parking lots and empty mall spaces with dense, dynamic neighbourhoods, these projects offer new opportunities for urban living while enhancing the overall functionality and appeal of mall properties.
​
Fig 3. Designed housing infill for a strip mall in downtown Seattle.
​
While the COVID-19 pandemic accelerated the challenges faced by traditional retail, it didn’t spell the end for malls. Instead, it pushed mall owners to become more creative with their leasing strategies, leading to a significant increase in foot traffic. According to a report by Placer.ai, malls that introduced innovative tenants, such as entertainment venues, enhanced dining options, and unique attractions like the American Ninja Warrior Adventure Park, saw notable increases in visitor numbers. This shift reflects a broader reimagining of what malls can offer, moving beyond just shopping to become multifaceted community hubs. Mall owners are now more open to shorter-term leases and diverse concepts, making malls more dynamic and adaptable. This creativity and willingness to experiment have sparked a resurgence in mall relevance, suggesting that the format may be on the cusp of a new golden age.
​
Opportunity
Investors should view the decline of traditional shopping malls not as a liability but as a significant opportunity for transformation and value creation. While the conventional mall model is declining due to consumer behaviour and market saturation shifts, these once-dominant retail centers offer a blank canvas for innovative redevelopment. Investors can capitalize on this by repurposing outdated mall spaces into mixed-use environments that integrate residential, office, and community-centric components. This approach mirrors successful strategies in the hotel industry, where private equity has revitalized underperforming properties through renovation and rebranding. By focusing on adaptive reuse—creating vibrant neighbourhoods, community hubs, and multi-functional spaces—investors can breathe new life into these properties, addressing housing shortages and meeting contemporary consumer demands. This strategic repositioning enhances the value of the mall properties. It revitalizes surrounding areas, making mall redevelopment a compelling investment opportunity with potential significant returns and long-term growth.
Conclusion
As we stand at the crossroads of retail's past and future, the demise of traditional shopping malls reveals a pivotal opportunity for reinvention. What was once a symbol of suburban prosperity now offers a blank canvas for innovation, where the remnants of these retail giants can be transformed into vibrant, mixed-use communities that meet the needs of a changing society. Investors and developers who recognize this potential are not just salvaging a fading retail model but are crafting the next chapter in urban development. By embracing adaptive reuse and leveraging strategic repositioning, they have the chance to turn the so-called "mallpocalypse" into a renaissance, creating spaces that are not only economically viable but also socially enriching for generations to come.
References
Verdon, J. (2022, September 4). The pandemic didn’t kill malls, it made them smarter, traffic report shows. Forbes.
Shopify. (n.d.). The future of malls. Shopify.
Urban Land Institute. (n.d.). Turning malls into neighborhoods. Urban Land.
Vander Ark, T. (2020, November 4). Turning dead malls into community assets. Forbes.
Business Insider. (2017, February 2). Dying shopping malls are wreaking havoc on suburban America. Business Insider.
EPOS Now. (n.d.). Why are shopping malls dying? EPOS Now.
PBS NewsHour. (2023, August 10). Why are malls across America dying? PBS NewsHour.
Marketplace. (2022, June 27). Rumors of the death of the American mall may have been greatly exaggerated. Marketplace.
World Finance. (n.d.). The rise and fall of the U.S. mall. World Finance.
Capital One Shopping. (n.d.). Mall closure statistics. Capital One Shopping.
CNBC. (2021, April 7). U.S. mall vacancies jump at fastest pace on record, hit high: Moody’s. CNBC.
International Energy Agency (IEA). (2024). Global EV Outlook 2024.
U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA). (2024). Short-Term Energy Outlook - June 2024.
McKinsey & Company. (2024). A Year of Electric Vehicle and Mobility Trends.
Resources for the Future (RFF). (2024). Global Energy Outlook 2024: Peaks or Plateaus?.
World Nuclear Association. (2024). Nuclear Power in the World Today.
Earth.Org. (2024). What the Future of Renewable Energy Looks Like.
Financial Times. (2024). Volkswagen Scales Back EV Investment.
This communication is provided for informational purposes only. Please refer to St. George Capital's research reports related to its contents for more information, including important disclosures. St. George Capital or its affiliates and/or subsidiaries may engage in trading as principal in securities, other financial products, and other asset classes that may be discussed in this communication. This communication has been prepared based on information, including market prices, data, and other sources believed to be reliable. However, St. George Capital does not warrant its completeness or accuracy, except concerning any disclosures related to St. George and/or its affiliates and an analyst's involvement with any company (or security, other financial product, or other asset class) that may be the subject of this communication.
Any opinions and estimates constitute our judgment as of the date of this material and are subject to change without notice. Past performance is not indicative of future results. This communication is not intended as an offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any financial instrument. St. George Capital does not provide individually tailored investment advice. Any opinions and recommendations herein do not consider individual client circumstances, objectives, or needs and are not intended as recommendations of particular securities, financial instruments, or strategies to particular clients. You must make your own independent decisions regarding any securities, financial instruments, or strategies mentioned or related to the information herein. Periodic updates may be provided on companies, issuers, or industries based on specific developments or announcements, market conditions, or any other publicly available information. However, St. George Capital may be restricted from updating information contained in this communication for regulatory or other reasons.
This communication may not be redistributed or retransmitted, in whole or in part, or in any form or manner, without the express written consent of St. George Capital. Any unauthorized use or disclosure is prohibited. Receipt and review of this information constitute your agreement not to redistribute or retransmit the contents and information contained in this communication without first obtaining express permission from an authorized officer of St. George Capital.
Copyright 2024 St. George Capital. All rights reserved.